My eyelids have a crease in them that some people don’t have, this crease can make wearing eyeliner annoying. Eyeliner usually smudges above my eyelid due to the natural curve of my eyelids, which means I have to reapply eyeliner and keep cleaning it up. My latest eyeliner is Dolce and Gabbana glam liner though and it is waterproof so it stays on rather well. It is liquid but it dries quickly and I don’t have anymore smudging!! It is the best liner that I have found so far. The color is called Black Intense if you want to be a copycat.