This one is a keeper. I felt like I took a chance since it’s from CVS and not somewhere like Ulta, but I’m impressed. It’s buttery, lasts a long time, and the matte is soft, not a harsh one. I just wish it didn’t transfer, it does transfer a bit onto cups. Besides that it has a nice color, sweet taste, and smell, and it is of decent quality. The shade doesn’t quite match how it looks in the tube, but it’s close enough.